Evaluating the healthiness of chain-restaurant menu items using crowdsourcing: a new method.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To develop a technology-based method for evaluating the nutritional quality of chain-restaurant menus to increase the efficiency and lower the cost of large-scale data analysis of food items.
DESIGN: Using a Modified Nutrient Profiling Index (MNPI), we assessed chain-restaurant items from the MenuStat database with a process involving three steps: (i) testing 'extreme' scores; (ii) crowdsourcing to analyze fruit, nut and vegetable (FNV) amounts; and (iii) analysis of the ambiguous items by a registered dietitian.
RESULTS: In applying the approach to assess 22,422 foods, only 3566 could not be scored automatically based on MenuStat data and required further evaluation to determine healthiness. Items for which there was low agreement between trusted crowd workers, or where the FNV amount was estimated to be >40 %, were sent to a registered dietitian. Crowdsourcing was able to evaluate 3199, leaving only 367 to be reviewed by the registered dietitian. Overall, 7 % of items were categorized as healthy. The healthiest category was soups (26 % healthy), while desserts were the least healthy (2 % healthy).
CONCLUSIONS: An algorithm incorporating crowdsourcing and a dietitian can quickly and efficiently analyze restaurant menus, allowing public health researchers to analyze the healthiness of menu items.
Research topics
Related publications
View all publications- Jones JB, Bruce CA, Shah NR, Taylor WF, Stewart WF.Transl Behav Med. 1(1):123-33. doi: 10.1007/s13142-011-0023-5.2011 Mar 01
- Lv N, Xiao L, Simmons ML, Rosas LG, Chan A, Entwistle M.J Med Internet Res. 19(9):e311. doi: 10.2196/jmir.7831.2017 Sep 19
- King SC, Weber AJ, Meiselman HL, Lv N.Food Qual Prefer. 15(7–8):645–653.2004 Oct 01
- Top Clin Nutr. 18(4):291–300.Lv NCason KL.2003 Oct 01
- Lv N, Brown JL, Liu B.Top Clin Nutr. 22(3): 258-271.2007 Jul 01




