Jump to content

Choose locationChoose Location
  • Sign in or Enroll
    • Open I want to choose my medical group or hospital
    • Clear my location
Change Location
Sutter Health
  • Video Visits
  • Find Doctors
  • Find Locations
  • Treatments & Services
  • Locations
  • Sign in or Enroll
    • Video Visits
    • Find Doctors
    • Find Locations
    • Treatments & Services
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • Pay a Bill
    • Symptom Checker
    • Get Care Today
    • Health & Wellness
    • Classes & Events
    • Research & Clinical Trials
    • For Patients
    • About Sutter Health
    • Giving
    • Volunteering
    • Careers
    • News
    • For Medical Professionals
    • Other Business Services
Close Search
  • Home
  • Ask an Expert
  • ACL Tear or Arthritis in Knee?
Content

Ask An Expert

ACL Tear or Arthritis in Knee?

C. Scott Walthour

C. Scott Walthour, M.D.

Sutter Gould Medical Foundation

Memorial Medical Center Modesto

Sutter Tracy Community Hospital

Question:

I had an X-ray and MRI on my right knee for severe pain. The radiologist said there was an ACL tear, but my doctor attributed it to arthritis. I don't have swelling and the pain is intermittent. If it were arthritis, wouldn't I have other symptoms?

Answer:

This is a complicated question, so I'll try to break it down into two issues.

First, let's talk about the ACL tear diagnosis. The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is one of the four main stabilizers of the knee. It provides support for the knee when twisting and turning maneuvers are performed. Injuries to this ligament are quite common, particularly in the young, athletic population. The classic symptoms of an acute ACL tear include significant pain, swelling, and often a "pop" or "tearing" sensation as the ligament ruptures. Most people can't walk immediately, and the injury is often severe enough that a doctor's visit or trip to the ER ensues. Chronic, or long-standing, ACL tears cause symptoms of instability or giving way, mainly with cutting, pivoting or jumping activities. Actions like normal walking, sitting, or standing often are painless and are easily performed. Treatment is tailored to the individual patient - surgery to reconstruct the ACL is very common in the athletic population, while therapy and bracing are very reasonable for patients with a more sedentary lifestyle.

Arthritis, on the other hand, involves the wearing down of the cartilage cap on the end of the bones in joints. This process can occur because of an injury or a disease, but it is most commonly seen as part of aging. Osteoarthritis, or degenerative joint disease, often manifests as pain, stiffness, and limitations in motion. The pain is often described as an "ache", but it can be sharp and deep as well. It normally progresses slowly, but it definitely can progress over time. Treatment is aimed at decreasing the symptoms and maintaining a normal lifestyle. Medications for pain, injections, physical therapy, braces, cane usage, and sometimes surgery all have a role in the treatment of arthritis, but the treatment is definitely dependent on the how severe the pain, stiffness, and swelling are.

So, this question mentions both a ligament tear and arthritis. Both can coexist in the same knee, but the only way to know for sure is to have an experienced doctor or surgeon perform a thorough exam.

Related Questions

Question
  • Painful Pops and Cracks in Knees
    My knee pops out consistently when I work out. I'm 19 years old, at a healthy weight, and have an active lifestyle. I have quit working out several times due to painful cracks and pops. Is there anything that I can do to prevent this from happening?
  • Knee Pain
    I've been having problems with my knee hurting when I bend it or straighten it out. What can I do to help the pain, and should I see a doctor?
  • Knee Strengthening Exercises After Surgery
    Are there certain exercises I can do after knee replacement to strengthen my knees to allow for climbing stairs easily?
  • Swelling Behind Knee
    Why might I get swelling behind my knee when I run?
  • Non-Surgical Treatment for Knee Arthritis
    I have arthritis in my knees. What are some alternative forms of treatment instead of surgery? I've had cortisone shots, but they are ineffective now.

Back to Bones, Joints and Muscles

The Sutter Health Network of Care
Expertise to fit your needs
Primary Care

Check-ups, screenings and sick visits for adults and children.

Specialty Care

Expertise and advanced technologies in all areas of medicine.

Emergency Care

For serious accidents, injuries and conditions that require immediate medical care.

Urgent Care

After-hours, weekend and holiday services.

Walk-In Care

Convenient walk-in care clinics for your non-urgent health needs.

About Sutter

  • About Our Network
  • Annual Report
  • Awards
  • Community Benefit
  • Contact Us
  • News
  • Giving
  • Find Care

  • Birth Centers
  • Care Centers
  • Emergency Rooms
  • Hospitals
  • Imaging
  • Labs
  • Surgery Centers
  • Urgent Care
  • Walk-In Care
  • View All >
  • Featured Services

  • Behavioral Health
  • Cancer Services
  • Family Medicine
  • Home Health and Hospice
  • Orthopedics
  • Pediatrics
  • Pregnancy
  • Primary Care
  • Women's Health
  • View All >
  • Patient Resources

  • Accepted Health Plans
  • Classes and Events
  • Estimate Costs
  • Health and Wellness
  • Medical Records
  • Medicare Advantage
  • My Health Online
  • Pay a Bill
  • Symptom Checker
  • Our Team

  • For Employees
  • Physician Careers
  • Recruiting Events
  • Residencies and Fellowships
  • Sutter Careers
  • Vendors
  • Volunteers
    • ADA Accessibility
    • Contact
    • Privacy
    • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

    • LinkedIn Opens new window
    • YouTube Opens new window
    • Facebook Opens new window
    • Twitter Opens new window
    • Glassdoor Opens new window
    • Instagram Opens new window

    Copyright © 2022 Sutter Health. All rights reserved. Sutter Health is a registered trademark of Sutter Health ®, Reg. U.S. Patent & Trademark office.

    Cookie Policy

    We use cookies to give you the best possible user experience. By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. Privacy Policy Cookie Preferences

    Privacy Policy Cookie Preferences